Thanks everyone
We also took the NJ Transit from Newark to NY Penn Station. The hotel is a quick 5 min walk from there. However, it was easier for us since we only had one rolling suitcase.
We took a sky cab, using a promotional price we found on the web.
I used Juno, which is a competitor to Uber. They did a good job and they were in Beta testing, so it was 30% less.
Uber or Taxi will be $50+ or you can take the train, NJ Transit, from Newark to New York Penn Station for around $13. Hotel will be a few blocks walk from there.
Super shuttle might be cheaper.
Taxi, uber
I suppose you could take aTaxi, Uber
Uber
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.