Address: 13616 Bothell Everett Hwy, Mill Creek, WA 98012, USA
Phone: +14257428500
Sunday: Closed
Monday: 10AM–6PM
Tuesday: 10AM–6PM
Wednesday: 10AM–6PM
Thursday: 10AM–6PM
Friday: 10AM–6PM
Saturday: 10AM–6PM
Don Rufo
I was fortunate enough to meet Chuck when I was having some items assessed. I could not be more pleased with the manner in which I was treated by Chuck. He was more than fair in his evaluation of my items. The store is magnificent and they have some amazing items. I am grateful to Chuck and it was a fantastic experience overall. I will ALWAYS go to Mill Creek Sports first before considering any other seller.
Scott Riddle
I give it two stars simply because they are nice or the one guy is. However, I would recommend not selling anything to them. I was told they payouts 50% of eBay sales. Meaning if your card sold for $100 on eBay, they will offer 50%. The first time I walked in there with a 2021 Mosaic Choice Fernando Tatis Jr Autograph, Shohei Ohtani black & Gold #/8, and Shohei Ohtani #/64.. They offered me $100.. I laughed at that one and walked out. I came back 3-4 weeks later, with the Ohtani #/8, Christian Pache Wave refractor Stadium Club Chrome, and those wave cards are a 1:112 pack hit. One sold for $100 on eBay. Also, a gold foil is Kelenic & India. Lastly, I had the Ohtani blue #/150 and the Acuna purple #/75 jumbo box toppers '86 retro cards.. I was offered $30 in store credit.. haha.. He did mention he couldn't confirm the #/8 Shohei, even though a gold #/10 sold for $300 recently, which tells me my choice and rarer card is a bit more valuable. They don't have to buy anything, fine with me, but to lowball people like that, it makes me wonder just how many folks they take full advantage of.. Anyway, some of the sealed product prices are really good.. Just be very aware when selling these guys stuff, they'll get ya.. Good day..
Brian Casey
BEWARE of Total Scam, when they post on website, "open authentication" or "onsite autograph authentication" during a so called 3/7/22 Beckett onsite show. I drove over from North Idaho to get a signature authenticated at Mill Creek Sports during an open authentication from Beckett. This was after speaking with Brett on the phone. He told me to bring my things in BAS would be there doing onsite autograph authentications. The very unprofessional male counter person was very rude and unhelpful . So I asked for Brent as I spoke with him on the phone, Brent told me he did not know when they would be there and I could leave my stuff and pick it up next week that BAS was still not there. I gathered up my things and left very disappointed. So I thought I would investigate a little. So I had my wife (from another location) call Mill Creek Sports and say she had an item to "authenticate", if she could bring it right down. She was informed that she "just missed them that they had just left". Then I had a friend call and ask if BAS was still there today and she was informed " yes they are here and will be until late because they are super busy". So I called BAS and all I could reach was a person in India, that didn't know how to get a hold of anyone that could tell me if BAS was at Mill Creek Sports, until I told him about the calendar he went to their website and looked at their events calendar while he put me on a lengthy hold. Same thing happened when I called Tuesday about where they will be today by a BAS worker, in India I asked to speak with her manager, she could not do that, I asked who she worked for ? She said Beckett, so I asked for the number in Texas, she could not produce that either. I was also told by Brent at Mill Creek that BAS would not be there on Tuesday as the calendar read. So Tuesday I called Mill Creek Sports and the woman answered, I asked if BAS was there today? She told me they were there and very busy. Mill Creek Sports has shown me a pathetic display of greed and dishonesty also has wasted my time, gas and money. I still have not seen a Beckett authenticator there onsite open authentication.? Maybe Brent can produce the names of the authenticator(s) not the company name that Mill Creek Sports told me and 2 others were there? Or even the authentic phone number to Beckett in Texas, not India. They might know who was or wasn't authentically at Mill Creek Sports. I am eagerly waiting for an honest answer, not an excuse on why the public was kept from BAS when they were there. Maybe its like a "book signing but the author is not there"
Andrew Komula
Mill Creek Sports is always helpful and honest when it comes to buying or selling. Their prices are fair and I always have a great experience with them. I drive all the way from Olympia to come here in particular. This shop is by far the best, I highly recommend!
Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.
Are they signed?
They will only purchase autographed items either authenticated by Beckett or PSA DNA or items previously signed at their store through one of their signings. Autographed cards issued by one of the major card companies like Topps is also acceptable.
You will need to contact the store directly and provide them the list of what you have to offer. I am pretty sure though that they will only consider autographed cards that were officially issued by a manufacturer like Topps or authenticated by a 3rd party grading service such as PSA or Beckett.
We can take a look at them.
Very safe, mask required
Hello, Owen Nolan is probably the biggest name in that era. If he is on there, I would guess the retail value is in the $150 - $200 range. Hope this helps!
Hello, It is really hard to say without seeing the baseball. Feel free to give us a call and we can try to help you with the authentication and an approximate value. Have a good day!
Mill Creek sports can do that for you. Call them up or take it in
Hello Brian, We sell a wide variety of cases and supplies for cards. Unfortunately at this time we are not able to send in cards for grading for our customers. We can definitely help you with if you have any questions. Feel free to give us a call.
Hello! We are working on some ideas and will hopefully start that again soon. If there is anything you are looking for, let me know and I will get you the best price we can. Have a good day!
They will look at high end or older cards. Anything after about 1980 needs to be a high-end card or signed.
Hello, We do buy cards, just depends on what they are. Feel free to give us a call and we can discuss what you have. Thanks!
Yes u can or go to their site on the internet... If u call ask for Brent or chuck... Tell them Bret sent you... I'm a regular their... They r high quality legit dealers in the memorabilia business... Classy group
GET THERE EARLY AND BRING A CHAIR. PEOPLE ARE FRIENDLY AND WILL WATCH YOUR PLACE OF YOU TAKE OFF FOR A BEVERAGE OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. GOOD TIMES.
They will if it is authenticated and if it is someone they are interested in. Remember whatever they will pay is going to be less than retail. They have retail overhead to meet.
Doug, most of their signed stuff is authenticated by Beckett or PSA DNA, a 3rd party authentication service. As for their signings, Mill Creek stands by their items. They are the official autograph source for Russell Wilson and Ichiro just to name a few. Very reputable and they don't deal in fakes.
Yes plus bat's helmet bases and cards
Probably only vintage cards before 1979 and preferably certified by Beckett or PSA. Forget about bringing anything from 90's. They may look at high priced inserts or certified autographed cards pulled from packs. Condition is everything.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.
Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.