Elliott Bay Pizza & Pub

Matt Shursen

This gem is a family favorite! Has bar and restaurant section and decent seating for both. Staff is friendly and great. From their signature pizzas to sandwiches their food is superb!!

Jacob Munoz

Okay, it's hard to find really good subs here in Washington. You've got the run of the mill places that barely meet your needs, but really good subs are hard to find. Thankful I live pretty close to Elliott Bay in Mill Creek. The bread is made everyday in house. If you know anything about subs, the bread is the make it or break it ingredient. This is where they shine. It's light and airy on the inside, and crispy on the outside. Perfect. The Maui Gold Sub is crazy. It's neck and neck with the Italian Sub. Those two are hands down the best. The pizza is good and so are the calzones, but the subs are out of this world. It's not the cheapest place to eat, but well worth the price of you eat there once in a while. The have a massive beer selection. I don't drink but my wife loves the choices she has. Give it a go. Batta-bing!

Anya B

Pizza is great at this spot. Probably better than some of the surrounding areas but getting takeout is kind of a hassle. Have called in pizza twice before and both times had to wait 15-25 minutes in the store because they hadn’t started my order until I got to the store. Decided to just walk in last time and had to wait 30min. Turns out they had forgotten to tell me the pizza was ready so if you do, do takeout I recommend checking in with them after about 15min.

Honesty Is the Key!

This was our first time ordering from here. We were very disappointed because the reviews say they have the best pizza & it’s ok. We ordered the large 14 in. cheese pizza which was expensive $18.25, BBQ wings $12.95 & full garlic cheese bread $9.50. My teenager loved the wings but didn’t care much for the pizza & he loves pizza. I kind of enjoyed the garlic cheesy bread, you can never go wrong with carbs. Warmed up the leftovers tonight… not so good. 👎🏼