Baseball Card Exchange

Category: Sports memorabilia store

Address: 709b US Hwy 41, Schererville, IN 46375, USA

Phone: +12193190197

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–5PM

Monday: 10AM–7PM

Tuesday: 10AM–7PM

Wednesday: 10AM–7PM

Thursday: 10AM–7PM

Friday: 10AM–7PM

Saturday: 10AM–5PM

Reviews

Steven Smith (ubertiss)

Sep 29, 2022

Very rude staff. I can't tell you who I dealt with as he didn't even introduce himself. No hi or welcome, no what brings you in today, I was literally welcomed into the store with "what do you want?"

Jeremy Murphy

Sep 15, 2022

Like em, use em. Will continue to do so.

C Family

Sep 15, 2022

No backing behind authentication service. What's the point?

Taylor Rains

Sep 4, 2022

New Shop looks awesome!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

do you buy cards from early 90's too about 2006

doloris calcaterra | Oct 17, 2020
Robert Sommer | Oct 17, 2020

Only specialty cards game worn memorabilia and signature cards

do you sell authetic football or hockey players autographed jerseys

Barbara Cable | Oct 17, 2021
Baseball Card Exchange | Oct 17, 2021

Yes we do, most can be found on our eBay store but we do have them in our retail store as well. Thanks

Hi how are you doing? Just to let you know someone on yt purchased a 1979 topps unopened box and they said they paid 2000.00 dollar's for box. They live streamed and said you searched box. I don't believe them

Shaun Sweeney | Oct 18, 2019
Shaun Sweeney | Oct 18, 2019

1979 baseball Sir. I do not v Believe them at all. I think they are trying to get free stuff. I make videos on you tube exposing dishonest channels and companies. Ty my friend

Do they sell individual common cards to help complete my set? Will they trade common cards to help me get rid of hundreds of doubles I don’t need or want?

Antler Jones | Oct 18, 2019
Benjamin | Oct 18, 2019

They have tons of boxes of commons, plus a huge online inventory. As far as trading commons for commons I couldn't say

I have a Michael Jordan collection consisting of over 600 cards plus other memorabilia such as leather bound Sports Illustrated magazines, a watch, plaques, etc. I am looking for an appraiser and buyer. Can you help?

Scott Hall | Oct 18, 2018
Patrick Connelly | Oct 18, 2018

They will give you a round about number what they believe everything is worth, but will not give you an appraisal. If they are interested, thay will make you an offer

Do you buy autographed items and slabbed cards?

Daniel Johnson | Jul 19, 2022
Brian Rudy | Jul 19, 2022

Slabbed cards and boxed set

Do they authenticate autograph photos

Robert George | Dec 21, 2021
Baseball Card Exchange | Dec 21, 2021

Robert, we do not authenticate autographs ourselves, but we do have PSA/DNA come in every few months to authenticate autographs. You can check Facebook to see when they will be coming next and drop off all your items. Hope this helps, thanks!

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 17, 2022
Baseball Card Exchange | Oct 17, 2021

We follow CDC guidelines as much as possible. Our employees wear in the retail store wear masks at all times and we ask customers to do the same. We provide hand sanitizer whenever possible and ask our customers to maintain social distancing as best as can be. Thank you!

Do they buy autograph balls & helmets ?

Abraham Rangel | Oct 17, 2020
Stephanie Diaz | Oct 17, 2020

Best bet is to stop up there with it. My husband says they do sometimes.

Read More

I was wondering do you send cards out to PSA to get graded ? I would do it myself but worried I might screw something up. Looking to build a 1986 fleer basketball set of PSA NM-MT 8.

Hector Morales | Oct 17, 2020
JediJoe34 gaming | Oct 17, 2020

Psa has slow turnaround times right now. Beckett has been on time though.

Read More

I have an autographed 1991beckett magazine with and signed by Michael Jordan and would like to authenticate it, any ideas how I can get that done?

louis ortiz | Oct 17, 2020
Keith Culbreth | Oct 17, 2020

You can send it off to PSA (just do a Google search) or next weekend at Rosemont there is a card show and PSA will have a booth you can submit it to.

Do you guys evaluate soccer memorabilia and what its worth?

Javi Salazar 1 | Oct 18, 2019
Sandra Paloma | Oct 18, 2019

I would call them and ask If they can't i am sure they will guide in the right direction

I have a robin Roberts #59 tops card in excellent shape what is it worth

DONALD WATSON | Oct 18, 2019
Keith Culbreth | Oct 18, 2019

Card #352 1959 book value $20 mint condition

I have a mint condition authentic signed frank thomas baseball card i was wondering how much would i get for it

patrick lorenz | Oct 18, 2019
Nick Theodoratos | Oct 18, 2019

It depends on what card it is

Read More

Does this place appraise baseball cards value.

Frank Smith | Oct 18, 2018
The Optirealist | Oct 18, 2019

It's called a Beckett! Besides that they look on Ebay to see what it sold for and offer you 75% decreased off the price. Don't waste your time. They are wolves.

Read More

Hello. Lookimg for information on a 1925 pocket book. Official rules for umpires. It has the words safe or out on cover. Publishing company fisher and son from chicago,ILL. It cost 25 cents. But i can not find nothing about it.

Shannon Walsh | Oct 18, 2018
Patrick Connelly | Oct 18, 2018

My advice would be to give them a call, dealing with them in person or via a phone call will give you the answers you need

Hi I have a box of baseball cards I no long want and was curious if you bought them?

Heather Mladenik | Oct 18, 2018
The Optirealist | Oct 18, 2019

If it's cards for the 90s expect them to say no. Mass production have caused them to be worthless mostly. Exception are rare rookies. Or cards not produced on a massive scale.

Read More

Do you buy?

Jerry Grogan | Oct 18, 2017
C.R. Stoller | Oct 18, 2017

Yes they do buy. As do I. Depends on what You have.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places