Great Island Bakery

Michael Tarselli

Family-run bakery with a lot of heart near the beach in S. Yarmouth. Menu needs some updating; food would be familiar to your grandmother, but is a bit too simple & sweet for this reviewer.

Fred Martin

First, the baked pastries are fabulous: the round danish with blueberries, the apple tart, the chocolate croissant, everything. Then, bring home the fresh-frozen **CLAM PIE** and bake it in your oven. It is amazing!!

Jodi Redd

This bakery makes a really good key lime pie. However one day they can make it in one day and the next day they told me they needed two days. It was co-workers birthday today and we called last week to have it ready for today so they had plenty of time. When we showed up this morning they didnt make it and did seem to care. It was on the schedule in front of them. Just no big deal to them when it was for a birthday party and we ordered it a week ago. Very disappointed.-UPDATE: The bakery apologized for the mistake and gave us a free pie and it was delicious.

Ed DeVenne

Get there early for the best selection and be sure to pick up a few pecan rolls. They are the best and go great with a DD coffee!