Papa's Pizza II

Tasha Mayberry

I wanted to just email the feedback to the company but your website has no email or form to contact you. The first time we went here the pizza was great. My husband ordered from here. So I decided to order my pizza here next time. I always get light cheese with fresh mushrooms and I specify 50% or more less cheese than normal. So half the cheese they usually put on. Unfortunately there was a ton of cheese on the pizza. I ended up ripping the cheese off and the mushrooms come off with it. So it's just sauce and crust. If you're ordering light cheese specify maybe a sprinkle of cheese. Not sure how else to explain light cheese. By the way, cheese bothers me but in small amounts it's fine. It was burnt too so crust not edible but I know that's the new haven style. Specify not burnt if you don't want that. The sauce is great! The staff friendly.

mike ralabate

Excellent pizza, super nice people working there, very reasonable prices

Nick V

Best gluten free in town. All other places serve the same trash dough! Please don’t change it!

Jesse Vecchione

Good pizza at the price point. I'm not from Milford but it seems like Trenton style pizza mixed with New Haven (local) style. Enjoyed watching the family operation, reminded me of my childhood growing up in an Italian restaurant.