Anthony's Pizza

Joee Pineda

I had no clue there was new staff, which is why I understand why the place is empty. The other thinner young kid was making the Pizzas they were a lot better and the tickets weren’t misplaced. I called ahead to order for pickup I show up 40 minutes later and No Pizza because the lady who took the order misplaced the ticket, the guy making it he Pizza says I guess we misplaced the ticket or whatever but I can have it ready in 10 minutes, I’m hungry I have kids to feed so I wait. Towards the end the same lady who misplaced the ticket told one of the new kids you should take his money. Now that she won’t misplaced she make sure my money was taken not even an I am sorry we will discount you or something for my mistake. They lost a good customer.

Evelyn Martinez

The inconsistency of the pizza here is crazy. One day you get an excellent pie the next it's disgusting. Last pizza i had here had an unusual taste almost like spoiled. It was so bad we threw it in the trash. When a Pizza Hut pizza tastes so much better there's a problem.

Michael Santagata

I’d like to preface this review by saying that it pains me to provide a 3 star rating to this restaurant. The staff is friendly, and they recognize regulars, the food is fine, average for the area, and the prices aren’t bad either. As a matter of fact, the only reason I’m giving 3 stars is because of the dine in experience. There is something morbidly wrong with their fountain drink machine. All of the sodas taste very strongly like spearmint flavored gum and the staff doesn’t seem to know why. Two separate visits over a month apart this was the case. Now, the staff was very happy to offer me a different flavor when I first pointed it out, and even the second flavor was just as bad. The first visit that I noticed this issue other patrons complained of the same issue, and the staff tried the soda and also noticed it. I’m bothered that it isn’t fixed yet, because the taste is truly awful and I’m slightly worried it might be from the chemicals used to clean the lines. To point out, the first time I noticed this issue, over a month ago the sodas I tried were Diet Coke and root beer. Today was Diet Coke and sprite. My mom had water and her water tasted fine. As I mentioned, my experience at Anthony’s is always great, and I’ve been coming here for almost 10 years, but I would be doing a disservice if I didn’t inform the restaurant or other patrons of the soda issue.

Joseph Oxford

Who ever is readying this and is from New York? Or a relocate? Who is looking for THE BEST New York style pizza and calzones? As someone that moved back from Florida from Manhattan, THIS IS THE ONLY TRUE NEW YORK PIZZA that I have found to date that , when I close my eyes after taking a bite of my pizza, puts me right back in Manhattan taking a bite of Joe’s pizza. Yes, it reminds me of Joe’s Pizza on Broadway that we all went to eat at after a play. Today I ordered a Calzone, I normally get a cheese pizza and a half dozen of garlic rolls. This are, seriously the BEST and FRESH garlic knots. All i am saying is, GIVE THIS PLACE A CHANCE! Look at all the positive results. You will taste and smell Manhattan when you eat in this place. The young man behind the scenes is always making sure he does the best that he can, so dedicated. I believe he is the owners son. I think they have other locations not sure, only care about this one. LOL No I have nothing to do with the owners, I have no clue who they are, I am a pizza freak that’s all. I use to eat Pizza seven days a week. Now I’m down to four or five days a week. Ive tried all the pizza places around here”Stavropol in Grand Island and eustis location is awesome as week, Greek pizza and then FREAKING BEST GREEK SALADS YOU WILL EVER HAVE) The place downtown eustis that claims to have NEW YORK PIZZA that uses a Conveyor oven to cook their “NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA” ummmmmmmmm, yeah about that?! I visited about 30 to 40 pizza Restaurants in New York to New Jersey WOULD NEVER CLAIM TO BE COOKING NEW YORK PIZZA AND USE A Conveyor Oven. The owner does not know what customer service is, very unfortunate. The pizza is really, really good but WAY over priced for this area. What she does not know is her own guest are scared of her due to the way she treats people. Very sad but I hope one day she realized how she speaks and treats her guest. If she does one day, I’m be her first Customer that left due to her mannerisms towards her guest. Let me know if this helped you. Trying to increase the number of my reviews considering I eat out 5 times a week. Take care, JW