Black Otter Supper Club

Category: Steak house

Address: 503 S Nash St, Hortonville, WI 54944, USA

Phone: +19207796975

Opening hours

Sunday: 4–8:30PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 4–8:30PM

Wednesday: 4–8:30PM

Thursday: 4–8:30PM

Friday: 4–10PM

Saturday: 4–10PM

Reviews

Curtdogg11v

Jun 2, 2022

Had a great meal with a bunch of friends. Wait staff was very nice. Began with the soup and salad bar which was a good start and for the main course I chose the queen cut prime rib which you can see by the photo is anything but small. Plenty for leftovers the next day.

Andy Redlin

Apr 2, 2022

Drinks and food were great. Service was warm, welcoming and consistent. Bluegill (pictured) was good. Only small disappointmemt was in the serving size of the potatoes puffs. Seems like everyone that ordered fries or skins got a heaping pile and puffs you only get 6 that are the size of a green olive. It would be nice to get the self service salad bar back but I get it with covid and everything lingering. I just imagine the 3-4 employees working the salad bar could be so much more useful being utilized as servers or busers.

Zac

Mar 8, 2022

This is the go to for us. It's a hard choice between Black Otter and the Pine Tree but man the black otter does steaks like no one else. I ended up trying the ribs and holy cow where they good and HUGE. The half rack is big the full is a beast. You won't be disappointed from the food to the staff you'll get nothing but the best.

Anthony Moua

Jan 21, 2022

I had an amazing dinner here with my Father! Service was great, and the food is delicious! Definitely recommend!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do all of your employees wear a mask?

Betty D | Oct 7, 2021
mark jones | Oct 8, 2021

No they do not.

Read More

Gift cards ? 🤔

Timothy Coenen | Apr 6, 2018
Dylan Koenig | Apr 7, 2018

Gift certificates are available at the check in.

Read More

Do I need reservation on a Friday or Saturday night?

Ryan Sluga | Apr 6, 2018
Nic Wienandt | Apr 7, 2018

No, its first come first serve. They take your name, give you a number and the waitstaff will take your order before you're seated. Once a table is ready you are seated.

Read More

Do you have Mother’s Day brunch

Margie Ziereis | Apr 6, 2019
[email protected] Tlatelpa | Apr 7, 2019

I don't think so

Do they take reservations?

Aaron Beck | Feb 4, 2022
geri Guyette | Feb 5, 2022

We do not take reservations. You will register with our host or hostess when you arrive.

Read More

What's the average wait time if you go around 7-7:30 on a Saturday? I expect a long wait, just getting a feel for how long.

Christine Paulik | Dec 6, 2021
geri Guyette | Dec 7, 2021

Very hard to say as we have no idea how busy we will be each night. I can tell you most customers get her early. I am the owner and cook I have not cooked past 9:15 in well over a year. I wish I could give you an answer.

Read More

How much is the dinner for two special on Saturday night?

Diane Hawkins | Oct 7, 2021
Keith Krause | Oct 8, 2021

The menus are marked as market price fir most of the steak and lobster foods, due to price changes being so often.

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Apr 5, 2021
Bahrs 8 | Apr 6, 2021

Very Good

Read More

Do you serve desserts?

Peter Petzel | Apr 5, 2021
Isaac Geffers | Apr 6, 2021

Yes!

Read More

Are there curbside pick up for cut prime rib eye?

Tong Thao | Apr 5, 2021
Holly Drew | Apr 6, 2021

I'm not sure call to find out

Is your salad bar open and if so do you require masks and gloves? Are masks required by patrons and staff?

Betty D | Apr 5, 2021
Jan Meyer | Apr 6, 2021

Salad bar is shielded and staffed, sorta like Subway does, still the best food though!

Read More

Are you open for thanksgiving

Karen Diederichs | Apr 5, 2020
Karen Diederichs | Apr 6, 2020

Are you open Thanksgiving

Do they have anything for birthdays?

Carol Paulson | Apr 5, 2020
Sharon Hass | Apr 6, 2020

Yes

Read More

Does this place have outside dining?

Molly Ponfil | Apr 5, 2020
Lori Laabs | Apr 6, 2020

No

Read More

Is prime rib served every day? (Closed Monday) I know.

Arlene Gellings | Apr 5, 2020
Mahan Koirala | Apr 6, 2020

Yes. Best time to go in when they open. Place gets packed incredibly fast.

Read More

Open on Monday's?

deborah nelson | Apr 6, 2019
Barb Hannes | Apr 7, 2019

If you check website you will see they are not open on Monday.

Is the Black Otter Wheelchair accessible?

Erin Culligan | Apr 6, 2019
Perry Michaud | Apr 7, 2019

Yes it is

Read More

Do you serve perch on Thurs?

marcia schmidt | Apr 6, 2018
T Bohn | Apr 7, 2018

I believe they serve fish during the week, not positive about perch specifically. You can call to confirm...

What hours will you be open New Year's Eve? Doing anything special?

Carol Hendrick | Apr 6, 2018
Carolyne Quella | Apr 7, 2018

No idea. I'm their mailman

Do you take reservations?

Bethany Vande Kolk | Apr 6, 2018
Diane Hawkins | Apr 7, 2018

Nightly specials?

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places