J. J. Gandy's Pies, Inc.

Category: Pie shop

Address: 3725 Palm Harbor Blvd, Palm Harbor, FL 34683, USA

Phone: +17279387437

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 9AM–5PM

Wednesday: 9AM–5PM

Thursday: 9AM–5PM

Friday: 9AM–5PM

Saturday: 9AM–5PM

Reviews

Tim Lynn

Sep 7, 2022

One of if not the best places in Tampa Bay for pies, pastries and cookies. My personal favorite is the key lime pie. These are fancy restaurants' quality pies.

Robert Rosen

Sep 4, 2022

Best local place to get pies! It's a little hidden away, but well worth the find.

Patty Ritter

Sep 3, 2022

Tasty pies and baked goods. Worth the trip! Loved the key lime pie frozen pop dipped in chocolate. I ate mine in the car!

thomas wilkins

Aug 26, 2022

This place was always great. The staff was so helpful. Jeff and his sister so eager to please. Well those days are gone and so too the famous JJ Gandy Key Lime Pies.... well all good things must come to an end. Maybe go back to when you wanted to make great pies and great business relationships. Now it's an overpriced transaction and to be honest the pies are not the same and it started before Covid like 2019 may.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Sep 18, 2022
Bill Terbush | Sep 18, 2021

There is a sign as you enter that you must wear a mask. The sign directs you to proceed in a clockwise manner and to keep 6 feet between yourself and others. Staff was wearing masks and using gloves.

Read More

How are their blueberry pies?

Bill Meyer | Sep 19, 2019
Mike Gary | Sep 19, 2019

not only their pies great but the owner is just a great person he donates pies to our feed the homeless charity every year and I have never had a pie that wasn't great even the key lime cookies

Read More

Can you order a pie for Thanksgiving? When do you suggest to come in to your store to pick up a pumpkin pie for the holiday?

Susan Copersito | Sep 19, 2019
James Thomas | Sep 19, 2019

I've known them for 20 years I would not risk walking in to get a pie on Thanksgiving I would definitely pre-order they are a great family and have an awesome product have you ever tried the brownies

Read More

Are the any stores that carry JJ Gandy key lime pie

Deb Doane | Mar 22, 2022
Jim Smith | Mar 22, 2022

No, their key lime pie only sold at their bakery.

Why are they closed from 12/18 to 12/27? :(

Rob P | Sep 18, 2021
Mitch Ilson | Sep 18, 2021

Christmas break?

Any vegan options?

Vanessa Barber | Sep 18, 2021
Donna Angiolillo | Sep 18, 2021

Not sure. The staff is very helpful give them a call b

How do I have your cookies shipped to friends?

John Williams III | Sep 19, 2019
Sheilagh Yeh | Sep 19, 2019

They will NOT ship cookies. I did ask and was told they can't do it but customer can buy them, mail cookies themselves. I did try that using wax paper and bubble wrap around each cookie and most arrived unbroken.

Read More

How to store pumpkin chiffon pie, keep frozen till serve or keep in fridge after picking it up?

Nancy Fields | Sep 19, 2019
Jovan Johannessen | Sep 19, 2019

Mine never last that long!!!! JJ Gandy's is the greatest!!!!

Read More

Do you have a reciepe for key lime cookies?

Lynne Michaels | Sep 19, 2019
Roxanne Efing | Sep 19, 2019

They sell the cookies but you won't get their recipe.

Do you take special orders for a pie not listed for example strawberry rhubarb?

Kay Mcnaughton | Sep 19, 2018
John Tanczos | Sep 19, 2018

Yes they do.

Do you have gluten-free key lime pie?

Susan Brown | Sep 19, 2018
Marc H | Sep 19, 2018

No they do not

Read More

Can you tell me what restaurants serve your pies? I'm interested in Dunedin.

Theresa O'Lansen | Sep 19, 2018
Lisa P | Sep 19, 2018

Go to JGandy's and they'll make your cream pie fresh right then and there. Including small ones.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places