Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

Amanda Murphy

I think a lot of these low reviews are crazy! Came here for my birthday dinner and yeah we sat at a two top table and I really don’t care for small tables either but it isn’t enough of a reason to give them a one star. I loved the food. The atmosphere was so on point. Our waiter was great, not overly hovering but always there and attentive. Our pizza was to die for. So good. The beer selection was small but well thought out and delish. Would highly recommend.

Roman Moise

An absolutely perfect experience! I came in late, but still received top notch service! The Meating of the Minds pizza is amazingly good. Airy but filling crust is delicious, and the meats and cheeses on top are amazingly rich! I personally like a little more firmness under the crust, as it was a little floppy, but it was so good I didn't care at all! One thing that's a must try is the Hot Honey. I don't know what's in it but I want to buy it by the gallon! Instead of the usual crushed red pepper, the hot honey adds a tiny bit of sweetness and heat that compliments the pizza perfectly. More places should offer something like this!

Russell Jalbert

I've been waiting a while for the chance to visit Benny's, and it was well worth the wait. Got a very nice vibe, and a great pizza menu. Add the fantastic staff and bar selections and it's a new go to for out of town guests.

Sydney Ott

Big fan of Benny’s! Their spaghetti, cocktails, and desserts are always good. However, many visits I have tried different menu items that turned out to be less than impressive. On our most recent visit, our server was quite unpleasant and our pizza was absolutely burnt to a crisp out the outer crust. The bruschetta was drowning in too many tomatoes. It’s like the bread-to-topping ratio was way off! I don’t know if the standard here is to chill red wines, but we found this a bit odd as well. Annnnnd there are a few teeny typos! All that being said, Benny’s still has the best spaghetti in Wilmington, and the atmosphere is always enjoyable! We’ll continue to visit, it’s just taken time to know what dishes are and are not worth ordering.