The Goat Middletown

Rick Schmenkman

There is a reason this place is called The Goat. The food was superb! Our waiter, C.H., was fun and attentive. We lacked nothing, and we had a big party (15, including little ones). We'll definitely dine here again!

Ben Shaw

Trivia every Wednesday night at 7pm. Great food, incredible selections of quality whiskey, and good service. Very impressed. We'll be back!

Cory Colson

Amazing place! Service was great, food was perfect. Great menu options, with fantastic specials. We had two different house cocktail specials, both were unique and yummy. Paired with an appetizer, it was a great start. Finished dinner with a burger and tacos. Thier burgers are really amazing, with a huge selection of choices. Tacos were on point. They also have a great selection of pizzas, and after having their pizza roll app, I'm certain they'd be just as great.

M Berrier

I ordered boneless wings and the goat burger and hour and a half before the kitchen closed. The first time ordering the boneless wings were great in 2020. Then the 2nd time they forgot the mild sauce for the wings around November 10th. And now the 3rd time November 27 it wasn't good at all. They were hard. They're not usually this crunchy nor do they have a really peppery bumpy coating like this and usually the breading is lighter. The goat burger I ordered today was disappointing. The bottom bun was soaked and the burger was really oily and overcooked. I ordered pink on the inside, but got well done. Oh and no pickles spear. I feel like it was a waste of $21. I am afraid what the 4th time ordering from here will be like since it seems to get worse each time. Do they just do cruddy cooking on carry out???