Caragiulo's Italian American

r y l e e r o c h e t t e

Best Italian restaurant by far in Sarasota. Would give this restaurant 6 stars if possible. Great service, fantastic food, and for a great value. Had two entires, one appetizer, one kids meal, and three glasses of wine all for less than 100 dollars. We highly recommend this restaurant.

Sarah Davis

Really good experience here. We had reservations, so we were able to show up and get seated almost immediately. The food here was absolutely PHENOMENAL! We had the bruschetta, tortelloni, and tiramisu. The food came out quickly, and it was so fresh and tasty. The service was okay, we didn’t see our server very much and did have to wait a few times. However, our server looked really busy with multiple tables and had her hands full, so no issue there. We were in and out in less than an hour, even with the appetizers and desserts. Would highly recommend!

Cigdem Alkan

I love the atmosphere at restaurant. I love the drink white sangria . Calamari was ok I can’t say it was awesome but margarita pizza was great . Their mussels was delicious! Pasta is awesome . Thank you !

mk

We met a friend for an early dinner here. It’s a stalwarts in SRQ. We always sit in the bar area. Food is consistent, delicious and very reasonably priced. Lots of regular clients. The place is busy even in the summer. You can’t go wrong!