The Cookie Jar

Wineguy71

Disappointing!! Seen great reviews on this local bakery so, I was under the impression that it was good. I was definitely wrong. Picked up a beautiful decorative birthday cake for my wife. When we tasted the cake the sheer look of disappointment on her face said it all. I should have gone elsewhere. It did not taste like anything I had ordered. We will never be back.

Swrrly Grrl

3.5 stars… because they’re independent and locally owned and around a long time. Just had a strawberry rhubarb pie from here… without any strawberries or rhubarb in it. More like jelly donut filling. Donuts are decent. I guess I prefer a different baking style… too white flour.

Chamodhi Ravihansi

Best! We were there at Portland Head Light for sunrise and this was open on the way back. Blueberry bagel was out of this world! We also tried the Boston Cream Bismark and it was really nice without sweetness overpowering. Also had both hot and cold coffee. Highly recommend!

kt 03054

If you love old school bakeries, you need to try this place! Their donuts and pastries are to die for! We got donuts, a double chocolate cupcake..which my son devoured, and a gingerbread lady. Love this place and we always try to stop whenever we are in Portland!