The Webs staff had answered questions very quickly so I think the advice to call or email them is good. Webs had quite a selection of yarn and I'm confident that they will be able to help you.
I suggest that if you have the yarn label from the hat then you look at the palette of colors from that specific yarn. You'd likely find a color to coordinate. Or, their web site often has "we also suggest" yarns. Without your telling the specifics of what you seek (yarn weight, plies, twist, etc), I don't know what else to advise. You can always call them on their 800- phone number and speak directly to an ultra-friendly and super-helpful customer service rep. I hope you find what you need quickly, easily, and affordably.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.