The Mayton

Jonah Bishop

Decent hotel, though not what I was expecting. Online, this place exudes a boutique hotel vibe. In person, it felt like we were at any given chain hotel. Our room had noticeable dust on the walls, which was random. One of the towel hooks in the bathroom was also broken. The room has a "noise masking" (white noise) feature, but the loudest setting was still surprisingly quiet. We were disappointed by this, as the noise from the restaurant down below was considerable during the evening. There are hardwoods throughout the place, which makes it a little noisier than other hotels I've stayed in. Breakfast at the restaurant was good, though pricey. Parking is a trick, though you likely know that going into it (parking in downtown Cary isn't great in general). Overall, I'm not sure I would recommend this hotel to my friends or family. It's not a horrible place by any stretch, just not great.

Brannon Jones

I’ve stayed at this hotel on three separate occasions now; the first being right after it had originally opened for business. We loved it the first two times but this last time was terrible. This place has changed ownership and it’s like the hotel lost its soul. Most of the finishes/decor/furniture seem to have been reclaimed by the original owners. The new ownership have done a terrible job replacing the charm that once was in the place. Poorly spackled areas that are extremely visible and capped over light fixtures that used to be ornate chandeliers are but a few things that were found to be less than desired in our room. This is a great investment for the new ownership group because there are not a lot of hotels in the area and this one is in a great location. BUT the prices they are charging are for what this hotel used to be, not what it is now; 4 stars is pushing it and I’m sure that will be lost soon. So in short, a great investment for the new ownership but a bad investment for you. I am rating 2 stars instead of 1 is because the staff was absolutely great and have no control over the things I’ve reviewed.

Yusuf Matcheswala

My family ate lunch here to celebrate our daughter’s graduation. Highest reviews for food,service and ambiance. Everything we ordered was flavorful and prepared well. Staff was very friendly. Will come back here for more meals and celebrations.

Ashley Smith

Oh boy! What a place this is! My husband surprised me with a stay here for our anniversary! This hotel EXCEEDED my expectations! From the front desk staff (5/2/22- sorry I don’t remember names but there’s the date so they can be recognized if they worked that day), to the waitress Maya in the restaurant to the wonderful sweet housekeeper (5/3/22) that waited outside our room at checkout to give us more time! I mean it was amazing! I’m a Marriott girl but The Mayton is my new spot for sure. The complimentary bikes for rent are a cute touch that we enjoyed using. The rooms were clean and spacious! Room service the next morning was hot and speedy as well! I can’t say enough about this place! We can’t wait to return!