Gourmet Garage

Bobbie Kerns

What a delightful hidden gem! Apple pie was delicious and their cream cheese Danish was the best I've ever had.

amy thorpe

Wonderful pies. I am not usually a fan of apple pie bit I love theirs. Lots of interesting combinations. I loved the raspberry/rhubarb pie. The shop is located just outside of the downtown area of Bayfield. Definitely worth a visit!

Joanna Hansen

I made a custom order for a true blueberry pie and it was so worth it! The filling was exactly what we hoped for: full of berries, not watery, not too sugary. The crust was thin and crispy, no soggy bottom! Though I prefer an unsweetened crust, this one was great and not too sweet. Well done Gourmet Garage! When I'm back in Bayfield, I'll visit you again. :)

Christopher Taylor

Always a favorite when we come to Bayfield! We suggest going earlier in the day, in case you need to reserve a pie in advance, etc. The lake, a cup of coffee, and pie.....what else do you need?!