Amsterdam Castle NY Inc.

Elizabeth Dunn

Stayed here with a friend while traveling through New York. Very cute, kitschy armory renovated into a hotel that looks like a castle. Rooms are a good size. The bathroom was luxurious. Beds were comfortable enough, but the pillows were a little firm for my taste. You can't adjust the thermostat, so the room was a little warm. And the light-blocking blinds don't completely cover the window, so a block of light came through all night (and was worse starting at dawn, which is around 5am in the summer).

Michael Scarangella

Really amazing hotel. After Marriott after Marriott, it was cool to stay in a place with so much character. For as old as it is, the rooms are modern (and huge). Really cool place and enjoyed the stay. 45 min to SPAC

Shannon Wittman

What an absolutely beautiful place to stay. The rooms were clean as well as quiet with new bathrooms. The great room is simply breathtaking! Beautifully decorated with knights armor, Dutch artwork, and gargoyles. I felt like a princess!

Akshay GV

This is a cute little castle in the country side that is very quiet with large rooms and beds. The place is kept clean (including bathrooms) and the staff is super friendly, however, don’t expect a normal hotel experience. Starting with the check-in, the entrance is somewhere on the side and not in the front. It was hard to find it in the evening especially when you come with luggage. The rooms are spacious and bathrooms are clean which was great! However, the night got too hot and the AC was disabled due to the fear of AC units freezing. I don’t think its fair to keep it disabled in April/May because that isn’t freezing weather. We could not sleep most of the night due to how hot it was and I would not have guessed that windows can be opened since we’re not used to this in hotels normally. To add to this inconvenience, the telephones don’t have the ability to call the operator directly. The property has regular landline phones and additional headsets are distributed in the rooms. We have to call the hotel main number to reach the staff and I was in no position to do that in the middle of the night. Also, the hotel doesn’t provide breakfasts and when asked, their response was to support local businesses around instead. Maybe the restaurant should provide vouchers/coupons for us to use at these local businesses because the rooms aren’t cheap for such limited service. All in all, while the staff is nice and friendly, if you have no reason to stay in this area/country side, I would definitely suggest to try another place because there are some inconveniences here and doesn’t help while traveling for business.