Supreme Bakery

Category: Bakery

Address: 40 Main St, West Orange, NJ 07052, USA

Phone: +19737361732

Opening hours

Sunday: 7AM–5PM

Monday: 6AM–7PM

Tuesday: 6AM–7PM

Wednesday: 6AM–7PM

Thursday: 6AM–7PM

Friday: 6AM–7PM

Saturday: 6AM–7PM

Reviews

Thyana Jannah

Oct 12, 2022

I want to see the well-established family business continue to win. It’s why I have to honestly tell you these 9am cupcakes I purchased tasted like a stale edible brick. Hope this helps.

Linda Hamilton

Oct 10, 2022

Very polite, however you have to order a wedding cake to their criteria. For example I wanted a 3 tier wedding cake for 55 to 60 people. I would have to get a cake that serves 75 people. They charge $25 for the cake tasting. If you order from them thats deducted from the price of the cake which was $775. Also they asked me if I wanted to bring my own flowers? I was in shock.

Luis Carchi

Sep 21, 2022

Pending I don't know yet

Codey Ruch

Sep 3, 2022

Great shop. Been coming here since I was a kid, and the quality has never changed. Delicious desserts.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

do you make Tres Leches cake? Maggie

Maggie Joralemon | Oct 30, 2018
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2018

Absolutely. Its one of our best sellers.

Do you make German Chocolate Cakes?

J K Kelley | Jan 2, 2022
Sharon Walker | Jan 2, 2022

Yes, they do make German Chocolate Cakes.

Read More

Where do you park?

Ricardo Dacosta | Jan 2, 2022
Sharon Walker | Jan 2, 2022

There is parking in the rear and on street parking.

Read More

Do you sell springerle cookies?

Joyce Middleton | Dec 3, 2021
Supreme Bakery | Dec 3, 2021

I am sorry we do not make springerle.

when will there be music in the store?????? 50 years of service and they cant add in a speaker or small radio or something please!

Alicia Rahming | Oct 30, 2019
Scott Bennett | Oct 30, 2019

I am a local contractor who stops in there in the morning For a coffee and a roll. However my family and I have been buying cakes, pies, and pastries and such there for 30 years plus. It has always been a pleasurable experience. The freshness and the quality has always been above average. I cannot help but mention the lady Marie that works there in the morning. She is amazing at taking care of the customers. Everyday with a smile and And a pleasant attitude multi tasking like you have rarely seen

Read More

do you have lightning mcqueen cake

Yolma Alleyne | Oct 30, 2018
Big Muslim | Oct 30, 2018

I don't know about them but I know ShopRite in Kearny does. 🤔

Read More

How many people would a quarter sheet cake serve?

Susan Richardson-Murray | Jun 1, 2022
Al Crossley | Jun 1, 2022

From 12 up to 20, depending on how you cut it.

Read More

Do you delivery vis fed x or ups to flanders nl

Elizabeth Hearon | Dec 3, 2021
Bonita Williams | Dec 3, 2021

No

Is there any sugar free items

JOHN PEACE | Oct 29, 2020
Supreme Bakery | Oct 29, 2020

Yes we make sugar fee pies and cakes. Please call first to order before coming into the store. 973-736-1732

Can you make a pj mask owllet cake?

Liza Catea | Oct 29, 2020
Ian Heydecke | Oct 29, 2020

I think they can make that. Give them a call

You can make designs

Jesus Lopez | Oct 29, 2020
Ian Heydecke | Oct 29, 2020

I believe so. Just bring an image or design you want

Do you carry jam filled Swiss rolls?

Thandiwe Khonje | Oct 30, 2019
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2019

I am sorry. We do not.

Do they have Vegan options?

Jacklyn Yacenda | Oct 30, 2019
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2019

I am sorry. We do not have vegan options.

Is the bakery Kosher?

Eric Fleming | Oct 30, 2018
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2018

Yes we are kosher. Under rabbinic supervision of Rabbi Bernard Rosenberg.

Read More

Do you make Dominican cakes?

kelly mancia | Oct 30, 2018
Macdonal Mcdougal | Oct 30, 2018

They make tres leches which is a latin recipe and by the way its very good. If you want Dominican cake, try Sweet Sensations on Bloomfield Ave in Newark. They are a mom & pops store, delicious & inexpensive

Read More

Do you make kolache?

Emma Coulter | Oct 30, 2018
Monique Conte | Oct 30, 2018

Just call them

Read More

I just wanted to know if you guys are hiring?

Christen Simon | Oct 30, 2018
Christen Simon | Oct 30, 2018

May you give me the cell phone number of the manager, please?

Read More

Do you do delivery?

Fany Chavez | Oct 30, 2018
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2018

Yes we do on a limited basis. We deliver wedding cakes and to some local venues . We are also aligned with Uber Eats who deliver selected items from our menu.

Do you make lemon meringue pies

lynette lee | Oct 30, 2018
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2018

Yes we do

Read More

How much is half sheet chocolate

Stella Ansong | Oct 30, 2018
China Lingchong | Oct 30, 2018

Call them and find out

They had someone that speaks Spanish???

Marbe Dubon (Mabhe) | Oct 30, 2018
Richard Stolz | Oct 30, 2018

Yes we have spanish speaking associates and we have knowledgeable experienced counter clerks anxious to help.

Read More

Is there anywhere on the website or anywhere else that has the nutrition facts for supremebakery cookies?

Julian Riezgo | Oct 30, 2017
Big Muslim | Oct 30, 2017

Yeah ask the store for that information.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places