Tate's Bake Shop

Category: Bakery

Address: 43 N Sea Rd, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

Phone: +16312839830

Opening hours

Sunday: 7AM–4PM

Monday: 7AM–12PM

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: 7AM–4PM

Thursday: 7AM–4PM

Friday: 7AM–4PM

Saturday: 7AM–4PM

Reviews

Christopher DeNigris

Oct 11, 2022

2022 update: this place continues to close absurdly early. We were out in the Hamptons doing some apple picking today and thought we would stop at Tates after. We looked up what time they close around 4:15 and saw they were already closed. Impossible to go here unless you are a morning person who lives out there lol, they don't care about the rest of their potential customers. 2021: Drove out from Babylon. It's closed @ 4pm. It said it closed at 5. So frustrating that the hours at this place are so early.

Daniskil Or Daniil

Oct 3, 2022

Top G cookies best I rate this 10 women in the kitchen out of 10

Joy Wechter

Sep 30, 2022

What a fun place to visit. It's one of my daughter's favorite bakeries to stop at whenever we go out east. This time we'd stopped enroute to the Shinnecock Labor Day Pow Wow and were thrilled that we had. Everything looked so delicious that we knew we weren't leaving empty handed or empty stomached, as usual. Though there's often a long line, it moves relatively quickly, and gives you time to browse and pick up extra goodies. It's great for gifts as well as filling those personal whims.

Scott Dolan

Sep 26, 2022

Great treats, one of the highlights of our trip. This is the shop run by the creator of the cookies sold in the grocery store

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do you no longer make the ginger snap cookies I can't find them anywhere Thanks

Maneda Gatling | Oct 16, 2018
Tracye | Oct 16, 2018

Probably sell out before you know it... always happens that way.

Are you guys open?

Mren | Oct 16, 2019
Jodi Zammit | Oct 16, 2019

Probably faster to call

Read More

I LOVE the thin & crispy Oatmeal Raisin!!! Where can I find them in Tulsa. OK?

Debi Bell | Oct 16, 2018
Sabina Lino | Oct 16, 2018

I love The Thin & Crisp Ostmeal Raisin

Are the cookies available in large chain Grocery stores? My experience has been CVS only & they have been broken each time. Im south of Boston MA, in Brockton.Love the product when I was able to buy & enjoy it!

Danette Pomodoro | Oct 15, 2021
Gaulson Lin | Oct 15, 2021

Yes they are available in Stop n Shop. You should go to the Bake Shop. They offer fresh baked goods and pies as well.

I bought 8 loves of Irish Soda bread I only buy it every year from tates. This year it's soft not crispy on outside???Why is it changed??? To me that's not Irish Soda bread.

Phyllis Early | Oct 15, 2020
Tate's Bake Shop | Oct 15, 2020

Thanks so much for your business, Phyllis! Our Irish Soda Bread is usually crispy on the outside, but to crisp up your loaves, try putting them in the oven at 350 degrees for 10-20 minutes. Give us a call for more info!

Read More

Do you have any in Philadelphia Pennsylvania.

Elizabeth Nutter | Oct 15, 2020
Juan Tirado | Oct 15, 2020

Southampton, ny is the only Tate's bake shop I know. I buy cookies every week. Their amazing!!

Read More

are you making the irish soda bread yet if not when do you start?

Phyllis Early | Oct 15, 2020
Phyllis Early | Oct 15, 2020

same question soda bread??? when??

A few friends were gathered around a bag of Oatmeal Raisin cookies when someone said " I wonder if this is responsible packaging." We looked in for any signs of recycling on the packaging. Frankly we were shocked. Can you clarify your policies?

Andy Platt | Oct 15, 2020
r y SolarPanels | Oct 15, 2020

Give them a call and ask, they would be happy to clarify that you.

Do they have a outlet

Stephen Salomonson | Oct 16, 2019
Charles Rosoff, ASA, MRICS | Oct 16, 2019

No. But I'm sure everyone wishes they did!

Is there another phone # to call today 6/8 Sat? Almost closing time at 6 PM!!!!!!????

Arlene Stout | Oct 16, 2019
Katherine Marin | Oct 16, 2019

Ok

Is there another phone No. to call??? "All circuits are busy....pls try ur call again later"!!! Close at 6 PM.....now 5:26 PM!!!

Arlene Stout | Oct 16, 2019
Matthew Behne | Oct 16, 2019

They are not open this late. It's more of a morning and early afternoon. Operation

Hi - Just wanted to know if you've changed the recipe? I find the cookies to be very crispy. I have come addicted to the oatmeal raisin cookies. Before they were soft and chewy which I liked.

Janice Bombardier | Oct 16, 2019
Richard Thandal | Oct 16, 2019

Tate's has always been that crispy, even when you could only get them from South hampton

Read More

If ordered today, will cookies arrive by Christmas?

Elizabeth Smith | Oct 16, 2019
Tate's Bake Shop | Oct 16, 2019

Hi Elizabeth! Give us a call at 631-780-6511 to discuss shipping options and timing with one of our customer service team members.

Do you still have the cookie tins of chocolate chip cookies I wanted to mail some to my grandson at Temple university. ?

pamela turk | Oct 16, 2018
grandmapurple55 Purple | Oct 16, 2018

Oh i never send a tin go on their website

Read More

I need to get orange cream cookies for my cousins are you still have in stock ??

Vikita Patel | Oct 16, 2018
Peg Rivard | Oct 16, 2018

Hi Vikita, The Oranges & Cream cookies are a seasonal cookie and unfortunately we are sold out. Watch the stores for our holiday cookies though! Thanks, Peg Rivard Ecommerce Tate's Bake Shop

Why do you not make peanut butter cookies ?

Deborah Dinnocenzo | Oct 16, 2018
Peg Rivard | Oct 16, 2018

Hi Deborah, Deborah Fleming is correct. Our baking facility is peanut free due to the prevalence of peanut allergies. We love peanut butter cookies too, but want to be sure everyone can enjoy Tate's cookies! Best regards, Peg Rivard Senior eCommerce Manager Tate's Bake Shop

Read More

I've been purchasing the chocolate chip walnut cookies for years. I noticed that the package I purchased today at Fairway in Pelham, NY had significantly smaller cookies. Still tastes great just disappointed that they've gotten so small. Is this new?

Tiffany Stanley | Oct 16, 2018
Tate's Bake Shop | Oct 16, 2018

Hi Tiffany! Because our cookies are handcrafted, cookie size can vary from batch to batch. So in order to ensure our customers are always getting their money's worth, our packages are measured by weight, not by cookie size. For example, if you've purchased a 7-ounce bag of Tate's cookies, rest assured you're getting 7 ounces of Tate's cookies. Enjoy 😊

Read More

I just received my order! Every cookie was broken in both pkgs. These were for a mother's day gift for my daughter. I don't have anything for her when she returns from her trip. She is gluten free for health reasons. Please tell me this can be fixed?

Alberta Whitebody | Oct 16, 2018
Megan Allen | Oct 16, 2018

Of course, Tates is very reputable. Call them and make a joke about " the cookie crumbling". Any one will understand. You still have a gift. Buy her favorite ice cream and use the cookies ( after you roll them into crumbs) as a topping.

Read More

Please bring back the ginger zinger cookies. Do you think they will come them back??? Your cookies are the BEST cookies I have ever eaten!!! Thank You, Sharon

Sharon Majewski | Oct 16, 2018
Megan Allen | Oct 16, 2018

Check in occasionally, they may come back. Personally, I adore the Vanilla Cookies.

Read More

What happen to the butterscotch pecan cookies? I can't find them!!

Laurel Renteria | Oct 16, 2018
Anthony Guzman | Oct 16, 2018

Call them

Are all the cookies gluten free?

Deborah Morgan | Oct 16, 2018
Deborah Morgan | Oct 16, 2018

Thank you. I thought they were the way they were playing up gluten free. Give me the regular Tates.

Read More

how do I check an order

Tanya Childs | Oct 16, 2018
Michele Grif | Oct 16, 2018

Call them...

Read More

Does Tate’s Cookies still make butterscotch pecan cookies?

George Hoffmann | Oct 16, 2018
Deborah Johnson-Mosley | Oct 16, 2018

Not sure. I know they do pecan cookies.

I was just here.southhampton NY.on a trip.i got your oatmeal Raisin cookies.im going to try them.if my customers Iile

Iris. Fuentes Castellano | Oct 16, 2017
Vinnie Pinzone | Oct 16, 2017

There are no bad cookies there although my favorite are the chocolate chips. Their gluten free cookies are great toi!

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places