Sarpino's Pizzeria West St Paul

Angela Runnels

I got the classic. No spice. Though the uncured sausage was good. Impossible to pick up a slice without all of the toppings falling off after it falls limply from your hand. The cheese was barely melted. I am a big pizza fan but I could not eat more than two pieces. The best word to describe the pizza is “goopy”. I hate saying this but it was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. The delivery guy left my pizza on the front steps when I specifically asked for it to be put on the porch. I was not informed of its delivery until 15 minutes later. Edit: I’ve given them another chance. This time they managed to put my food on the porch but didn’t knock or ring or anything. I avoided the pizza and got the calzone, which was very good! The delivery is fast but they won’t tell you when you get your food. The pizza is bad but the calzones are worth it.

Patrick Molan

Made an order at 10:30 on grubhub. Called the place at 11:30 when it said my order should have arrived. They said they never got it but he would get it to me in 45 minutes. Called at 12:30 and asked if it was close. He said "no another 15 minutes" I asked him if he had even started it yet. He said "no because I want the pizza to be hot when it arrives." How could you deliver the pizza in 15 minutes when you haven't even started it yet. I told him to cancel the order. Also it takes calling at least twice to get them to answer the phone.

Nick Barton

I’ve been going to this Sarpinos for quite some time and have had some ups and downs with the taste and quality of the pizza. Never before have I received pizza that still had raw dough though. I’m not sure what exactly happened, but to send this product out is disgusting. Both pizzas I ordered yesterday had portions that were still raw. After this last experience, I’ll drive out of my way to go the location downtown if I ever order again.

Garrett Stewart

Awesome Pizza! I'm not sure why the average rating of this place is only 3.5 stars. Their pizza has been great every time I 've had it delivered, and the drivers have been friendly. My wife and I have quite different tastes when it comes to pizza and Sarpino's is one of the only places that we both really enjoy. I don't think it's either of our favorite place, but it probably is the only place we'd both rate in our top 3-5. This is why it earned the 5 star rating. I saw a couple people complain about the toppings falling off, and that's happened to me before, but I would attribute it to the pizza having 2-3x the toppings you'd get from a Domino's or Pizza Hut. That and the amount of moisture that can build up inside the box during the delivery. There's really nothing anyone can do about that, other than ask for light toppings or go pick the order up themselves, because I would imagine the average delivery spends 10-15 minutes in a box, which kills the crispness of anything.