New York City Pizza

Christi Hovater

We just ordered from this restaurant and ordered a large cheese pizza and breadsticks. We received a very cold pizza with mushrooms, sausage and onions instead of our cheese pizza (which my kids will not eat). Our breadsticks were also cold and covered in sauce which had spilled out all over the bag. I tried calling the store and nobody answered. Edit: I had spoken to them the following day and had been told they'd mail me a gift card due to the mistake. I was going to update this once recieved, but still haven't gotten over a month later. Will update if it ever comes lol Edit 2: The restaurant reached out and apologized last week and did send me a gift certificate for the full amount I paid!

Stuart Crawford

I hate to give 1 star reviews but the spiders, dead bugs and small flies on the ledge of our table warrant it. If they can’t take care of the front of house, what is going on in the rear.

Ryan Baldwin

ITS OK Let's start with the GOOD... The bartender was on point... The drinks were good and the bar was clean. The Greek salad was perfect. Now the BAD.... The meatballs were old and probably heated up in the microwave. The pizza THE PIZZA DID I SAY 🍕 It tasted like a regular pizzeria would make. I expect a lot better from NYC PIZZA... The chicken parm dinner is my favorite at NYC PIZZA NOT THIS TIME....... What a different place compared to NYC PIZZA in Bluffton

Tamara Zaffino

We go to New York City Pizza every time we come to Hilton Head. We like NYCP so much we get a pizza to take home to GA when we leave. 5 stars every time we go. 🙂