East of Chicago Pizza

Frank T

Mediocre at best at premium prices, but just about the only game in town on Sundays here. Do yourself a favor and grab fast food or eat leftovers, either will be better and you can save your money for a good meal at one of the excellent Amish restaurants the next day!

Dalynn Grant

Out of all the East of Chicagos this one is the best. All others that I have gone to messes up the order or it’s cold. Only problem is My last one my nachos didn’t have jalapeños on it but not a big deal.

Dustin Miller

Food quality matches other East of Chicago locations, however the people here are in no way geared for customer service. 1 younger girl running the register, answering the phone and bringing orders out. She didn't seem all that happy, but I guess understandably so. I saw a few orders stacked up on the pizza oven in the back, and no fewer than 3 other employees toward the kitchen who kept looking around the wall toward the front, and not 1 asked if I had an order and was willing to grab the boxes and hand them to me, as I had to wait for the younger girl to complete orders at the register and the phone. Fix these problems and it will be a 5 star review, because the food is great.

Mike Hardie

pretty decent pizza. we got the supreme, had green olives and yellow pickled peppers on it... nice!