The Incredible Pizza Co

Category: Pizza restaurant in Newark, Ohio

Address: 391 W Main St, Newark, OH 43055, USA

Phone: +17403454455

Opening hours

Sunday: 4PM–2AM

Monday: 4PM–4AM

Tuesday: 4PM–4AM

Wednesday: 4PM–4AM

Thursday: 4PM–4AM

Friday: 4PM–4AM

Saturday: 4PM–4AM

Reviews

Jadon Kelley

May 28, 2022

Great subs but I never liked the pizza to much, it's still worth ordering but the delivery can be slow sometimes

Destany Truex

May 13, 2022

Got pizza was cussed out by the driver because we were having card issues tried to take back the food we tried to pay for and said they get prank calls all the time he didn’t have time for this. Very rude guy. Said all the food that is left over the owner has to eat all of it that we shouldn’t have called to get food. Such a great place to get food 😂😂😂😂

Tommy bombs

May 3, 2022

Have had it many times enjoy it every time they are low staffed for the pure amount of orders they put out but verything i have gotten was delicious I usally order a chicken Alfredo pasta it's 9.99 and comes with a free garlic bread I add cheese to mine

Sheila Summers

Dec 12, 2021

I work the graveyard shift so when I need dinner they are open. This last time I ordered I was terribly disappointed as I order quite a bit from there. Food was so cold, I can't have red sauce and the sauce was covered on my bread like it …

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

I called and was on hold 10 minutes had to call back order my pizza and that was at 11 and it's almost one and every time I call they just say hold and leave me there this place is so unprofessional it's sad glad you never showed poor business skills

Kid Mccullough | Dec 26, 2018

tee Corbett | Dec 27, 2018

I'm actually surprised this place is still open it has went fully downhill used to be good pizza now I think they only get business because they're the only thing open after 11 p.m.

Called in and ordered at 11:30 and didn't receive the pizza till 1:59am Called in to speak with the manager 3 different times and only on the third time she said she would contact the driver. When he pulled up he reaked of alcohol, he should be fired

Aleigha Frenton | Dec 26, 2018

The Incredible Pizza Co (Owner) | Dec 27, 2018

He was fired!!!

upon research in to your business I now know that you use a old world secret recipe for your sauce. Why do you take the time to do this when you can just open a can like the comp. ?

Sum1 Johnson | Dec 26, 2019

Will Maye | Dec 27, 2019

The sauce has a unique taste that makes the pizza experience incredible. I love the taste. I haven't tasted any pizza with the same flavor as incredibles pizza. The blend of spices and the tomatoes are delicious.

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Feb 28, 2021

The Incredible Pizza Co (Owner) | Mar 1, 2021

We abide by the health department regulations.

This is really up setting no matter when I call ever time I have been placed on hold well tonight I called was placed on hold for 10minemts thought maby they forgot so I hang up and call again and get placed on hold again we’ll I wait and wait and

Anthony Graf | Dec 25, 2020

Russell Williard | Dec 26, 2020

Yea they probably forgot about you that's normal tho

how big is their cookie

Jazadrian Lyday | Dec 26, 2019

The Incredible Pizza Co (Owner) | Dec 27, 2019

2oz 2 per order.

i am trying to call and order a pizza, and the phone service must not be working. can i order it from here pls?

Adam Pfannenschmidt | Dec 26, 2018

J G | Dec 27, 2018

Sometimes they get really really busy since they are the only one open other then dominos. When you call you may get put on hold right away. If it's been a while just hang up n call back.

I ordered my food from select hospital on Tamerack ..was on hold for over 15 mins and 3 hrs later no food!!!! I called to confirm no answer!! Why is this!!!!!!!!

Angie Berry | Dec 26, 2018

Faith W | Dec 27, 2018

Just happened to me! The guy was super sweet but hella stressed the owner left ONE GUY and ONE DELIVERY DRIVER to handle EVERYTHING alone.all the phone calls all the food plus taking the food everywhere. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places