Original Italian Pizza Milroy

Jason

Excellent pizza and subs. The menu is smaller than some of the other OIPs, but the quality is better. Great owners.

Susan Keck

Service was quick in spite of the crowd what in for take out and only one waitress: hostess, taking orders delivering food, and busing tables. She was very friendly and made sure are food was great and our needs were met. Food was Awesome. We got a medium pizza that was bigger than what we normally get in the Arnold-Cape ST. Claire area. My husband and I had half for dinner and the rest for breakfast.

James Gieza

Should’ve just ordered bread with a slice of Turkey and a slice of cheese. Btw. This place has no deep fryer. So No wings, etc. also no wraps. Pizza is impressive though.

Rachel Keefer

Amazing! The one server is fantastic, she has a great personality, she is attentative and hilarious 😂 The food is amazing and delicious. Well priced for the quality and quantity. Good classic handmade meals! Definitely a new dot to add to our yearly vacation to this area!