1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

spaulay

My rating is based on service. We were seated and sat, and sat... and sat (about 20 minutes). The host and the waitress walked past us multiple times. We made eye contact and they'd turn away. We stood up. Still no service. We walked to the exit and said to the waitress that we were leaving because she'd looked at us multiple times and yet never were we approached. Her excuse was she doesn't know who our waitress is. Still no offer to attend to us, so we walked out. The food on the menu looked really interesting, but we weren't meant to find out. We walked down the street to the Market Street Pub where we were seated and attended to right away. UPDATE: The food at Market Street Pub is very good.

Nicholas Petrillo

This may be the best burger I’ve ever had. A lovely establishment, which sticks to its theme. It tells a brief part of history - the Whiskey Rebellion - and has menu items appropriately named. The dishes looked delicious, and tasted even better. My wife had the deviled eggs which were “devilishly” good. We expected 3 halves, not three whole eggs, so that was a great surprise. The Mifflin Bull Burger was fantastic, as previously mentioned, perhaps the best burger I’ve ever had. The onion rings were massive and perfectly cooked. Think of the sound of crunching leaves or fresh snow, you could hear the crackle when biting into it. The burger was perfectly moist and seasoned. The burger came with a house made ketchup on the side, but the burger didn’t need it. The fries were crisp and seasoned with just the right amount of salt. For dessert, a gluten free cheesecake. As one may expect, a vast offering of Whiskeys. Convenient location, this place was incredible!

Brett Wiley

Food was good, but we won't be dining here again. We went here as a date night and we're excited to try it out. The food was great, portions were small but quality was great! The service was inattentive and though the server was nice, did not seem genuine. We were there for an hour and our drinks were not refilled once even after checking on numerous tables around us. Overall it was just okay.

Josh Burke

We were really excited to try this restaurant while we were in Carlisle and had actually pored over the menu for days in advance. The food was good, not great, but the killer was the inattentive service. After we told our server we needed a few minutes, we were left alone for a quarter of an hour. No one checked on us, and my daughter finally had to flag another server down to refill our water. Once we ordered, it took at least half an hour to get our burger and some ravioli. We know everyone is doing their best these days, but we were literally the only patrons ordering food. If staffing was the issue, checking in on us once or twice as we waited and waited for our food would have gone a long way. A somewhat surreal and disappointing experience.