Elmer's Restaurant (Pocatello, ID)

Jeanette Rodgers

We came here on purpose after eating here years ago. No complaints about food or coffee. Prices seemed to be what's expected now with good portion sizes. Husband ordered blueberry pancakes with a good number of blueberries and the pancakes themselves were good. I ordered the potato cakes, just 2, but so filling that I couldn't eat both. It's nice that the items like pancakes and waffles come with eggs and choice of meat. Waitress asked if he wanted just the pancakes, so that must be an option, but the price on the menu was for the combo. Most customers seemed to be locals and this appeared to be a favorite place which probably means that they don't notice some things anymore, like the condition of the restaurant and restroom, which could benefit from some updates. We sat in the second booth and I had to sit closer to the window so that I wasn't sitting in a hole left by broken springs or something. Presentation of food, like sour cream placed attractively, is important. Ambience of a restaurant is important. The total package is important when it is getting more expensive to eat out and when there are a couple of competing restaurants with reviews that are enticing.

Medic Man

The stuffed hash browns were great! Not hash browns from a bag, homemade! The stuffed potato cakes were yummy according to my wife. I had the marionberry syrup on the pancakes was fantastic! Service was great! Definitely a do again restaurant.

Mason Jar

We had a group gathering here and it was a good experience. The staff was amazing! The food was really good. I thought the salads were a bit small and the fish and chips could have been less soggy, but overall everyone enjoyed their meal. Our waitress, Emily, was quick and efficient. Our drinks stayed full and she was attentive. She rallied everyone to sing happy birthday to my dad which was a nice touch! We were grateful we could make a reservation in the back room with the fireplace. Elmers has a nice hometown diner atmosphere.

Randy Springsteed (Tkrealm)

Clean with a welcoming environment. Quick service, food competitively priced and good although a bit salty. The polite friendly staff with their professional attitude only enhanced the experience. Good place to go either by yourself or with friends and family is ideal for a bite to eat or nice cup of coffee.