Gappy's Pizza

Steven Monsour

I have known the owner for almost a decade he has a hard working staff and good food there always in a rush to make sure your order is good and out within the time they specified there pizza is really good I recommend it and it is a well established place very busy on the weekends I have always been a happy customer when I go there for food highly recommended 10/10 rating in my book if anyone is still unsure check it out you won't be disappointed

Gabriela Gordon

Thursday night we went (me and husband) to get two pizzas to take home, it was not crowded and it was kind of late, like 8:30pm. I have to say that the service was very good, very nice girls and guys and very attentive. But the guy who made our pizza should be fired. We got dry, burnt pizza, with burnt brownish cheese on top. The bottom and sides were dark brown to black , very hard and dry. When I ordered they said 15 minutes. But I waited 30 minutes, so the pizzas were getting burnt in the oven while I waited. There is no excuse since the place was almost empty and it was late. I was so hungry and tired that I ate it anyway. But if I give them the benefit of the doubt and go back there again, I am going to be checking the pizza before I leave, and if it is burnt I will just give it back and get a refund

Nick Barrett

The food is always exceptionally tasty. The portions are extremely generous. Gappys is a staple of carmel and is one of my favorite places to go when I come back to NY. The pizza is, dare I say, the best in putnam. The prices are more than fair and the staff is always friendly. The turn around time for food is always quick. This place is worth a detour.

lisa diamond

My son took me here a few weeks ago & I forgot to leave a review. Chicken Parmigiano & Shrimp Scampi was so delicious. The sauce was excellent too! The staff were so nice & helpful. I am dying to try the pizza next time! Soon I hope. Thank you to my son Anthony & Gappy's for a wonderful meal