Smithtown Seafood

Shayne McDonough

Excellent fried catfish and hush puppies, but I didn’t care for the coleslaw. The catfish portions seemed small, but after mentioning it the waitress, another larger fillet was given to me at no charge. Friendly service, good food, and a relaxed atmosphere made for an enjoyable lunch. I look forward to visiting again.

Diana Smith

Delicious summer menu with many options that stay on the menu year round. Quick service, hot food and delicious. Salmon croquettes were delish. The house salad was good but the ginger vinaigrette was the best. Shrimp taco was good. Fried banana peppers were great too. Step over for a cider, ale, or IPA, from West Sixth, you won't regret it

Catherine Carpenter

Got fish and chips last night, which was nasty. Fish smelled bad and was greasy and coating would not stick to it. Fries were overdone and the hushpupies were hard as rocks and literally inedible. The slaw was good.

Anne Huber, REALTOR

We had been hearing about Smithtown for months and decided to have dinner here while having a beer at West 6th. It was difficult choosing what to order as the shrimp and grits battled fish and chips in my head, two of my favorites! In the end both myself and my husband went with fish since beer goes so well with that. LOL We were very happy we did as it was fantastic! Very crispy on the outside and flaky inside, served with two flavor-filled hush puppies and my favorite kind of fries. And to beat all, even their ketchup and tartar sauce was excellent. 👌🏻 My husband got the remoulade which had just a bit of heat, and I definitely I will get that next time.