The Putnam Inn

Category: Family restaurant in Greencastle, Indiana

Address: 400 N Jackson St, Greencastle, IN 46135, USA

Phone: +17656538777

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 11AM–9PM

Wednesday: 11AM–9PM

Thursday: 11AM–9PM

Friday: 11AM–9PM

Saturday: 11AM–9PM

Reviews

Laura Woodason

Jul 16, 2022

Ate at this place on the way home from baseball. The food was great. Our server was pretty great. But unfortunately we were not told about the price being higher with seafood so I was charged $40 vs. $20 because I had one cluster of crab legs. It wasn’t explained to us and the signage wasn’t clear. We won’t be back. Also, when I asked to speak to someone the poor waitress was sent instead of the owner. When I called to discuss it the manager said she would address that we weren’t told about the prices. It was a joke. I wouldn’t waste your money on a place that scams their customers into paying $40 a meal.

Paula Lopossa

Apr 25, 2022

We always try to go for their Cajun buffet 😋. It is always great but this year the Wednesday buffet night was exceptional!!!! Great place to eat at other times tpp.

J Y

Aug 8, 2021

Definitely check this place out on a Friday or Saturday. The seafood buffet is legit and so are the crab legs. The main buffet is $20 and an additional $20 for the crab legs. The frog legs and shrimp were good as so was the salad bar. Don't pass on dessert because the dessert bar is phenomenal!

Vicki Spach

Dec 10, 2017

Love their salad and hot bars and everything I've eaten here is excellent. Highly recommended for variety, generous portion sizes and healthy options as well as good deals on daily specials. It has a homey, comfortable feel, accompanied by friendly service. Take-out service has never disappointed. Also, they have a brand newly redone bar and conference room that are beautifully decorated. Such a nice new change with a still comfortable and yet sleek atmosphere. Great daily drink specials, too. Thought I'd add some pics of the new remodel.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do kids eat free on Tuesday?

Kenny Knox | Aug 5, 2020
Rhonda Brotherton | Aug 6, 2020

Yes they do!

Read More

Do you still serve crab legs?

Monica Kincaid | Aug 6, 2018
Weiwei Chao | Aug 7, 2018

I had never had crab legs in this restaurant.

Read More

Do they have seafood

Lynda Starr | Oct 9, 2020
ginger lovett | Oct 10, 2020

Yes

Read More

Are you Serving breakfast

Bonnie Birdwell | Oct 9, 2020
The Putnam Inn (Owner) | Oct 10, 2020

Hello! We are taking a break from breakfast until things get back to normal. I hope you can join us for lunch Wednesday through Sunday 11am-2pm and Dinner Wednesday through Saturday 2pm-8pm.

Is the buffet open again yet? How does it work now ? Thanks!

Lora Pine | Sep 9, 2020
John Byerly | Sep 10, 2020

It is open. They serve you cafeteria style. It takes a little longer but still the same great staff and same great food.

How much is cat fish dinner with 4 whole catfish?

Gloria Christian | Aug 5, 2020
Rhonda Brotherton | Aug 6, 2020

We could do that for $22. The dinner is served with fries, cole slaw, and hushpuppies. We don't have Catfish available every day so please call ahead to check for availability.

What are each daily Buffet? And what's on the seafood buffet?

Jamie Reece | Aug 5, 2020
Bri Bogle | Aug 6, 2020

Frog Legs

How much is the buffet

Debbie Ford | Aug 5, 2020
Ryan Blair | Aug 6, 2020

It's like 30 bucks for 2 people with soft drinks, but it's way worth it! They also have a full bar with different craft beers

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places