Cibelli's Pizza

Jeanna Mccarthy

Awesome New York style pizza!! I love that you can run in and grab a custom slice of your don't need a while pie. Their pizzones are really good too!

Robert

Very good pizza. The only small issue I have is that the crust is almost paper thin in the center of the pizza, so toppings, cheese and sauce are not supported by the pizza slice and fall back into the pizza box.

Robert Jordan

The 18" pizza with a large Greek salad were delicious. We had enough left over for a slice of pizza for breakfast in the morning!

james rustler

There are a lot of issues with this place now. Their website and google both say they are open mondays, they are not. That threw a wrench in my plans when I pulled up and no one was there. They scammed and lied to me when I went to pay the next night. The website says toppings are $3, when I get there, toppings are $3.50 instead. The “cheese sticks” are also a lie, half of it has cheese, the other half is cooked dough. I love thin crust ny style pizza but this was actually too thin, so it didn’t support the weight of the toppings and became soggy. The “stuffed crust” is also a giant rip off. Half the slices had so little cheese in the crust I could see through it to the other side. It seems to me they are trying to save money by skimping on the product and they are poorly executing what they do make. I also didn’t appreciate the aggressive signage inside the store that demanded the customer “not complain to the hard working staff and they could call him directly to complain.” Very fake macho and unnecessary. Needless to say, I won’t be back to this business.