American Pie Drive In

Jeanne Lynch

Good News vs Bad News. We got the 16" pepperoni pizza for 1st time, it was the best we've had on the outer banks. Expect $25. There is a $2 coupon in the book, and pay cash for additional discount. Highly recommend. This is owned by Miller's restaurant. Bad News: We went back to try the hot wings, advertised as a lb. Not hot and only 6 in order. Not impressed. We split 8" cheese steak sub with onion. Comes w/ L, T, M. Who puts raw onion on a cheesesteak sub? The meat was rectangular shaped steakum. Disappointing. Bread was very good. French fries were ordered extra crispy with a side of hot sauce but instead were soggy and limp with 3 packets of ketsup. Yuck. Fed to seagulls. Ice cream: i believe ice cream in made in house. Served in a cup. Interesting flavors like rum raisen and coffee. Butter pecan had pecan halfs so there weren't pieces with each bite. I personally would have preferred pieces to enjoy more crunch and nut flavor. They have a separate outdoor pickup/ take out window to avoid congestion inside. Get the 🍕 pizza ! The best on outer banks.

The Pennock's

American Pie has great Pizza. We ordered the American Pie: Double Cheese, Pinapple, pepperoni. The reason for 4 stars not 5 is the overpriced mozzarella sticks. We got an order to go and it was incredibly disappointing. 5 sticks for almost 8 bucks. Aside from that great pizza and lots of outdoor seating.

Shaun Muha

Fast, clean, reasonably priced. I placed my order online and even with a packed parking lot it was ready in 20 minutes. Good sauce to bread ratio on the pizza. Fair amount of toppings. Really good taste. My favorite pizza in the area. I will be sure to come again the next time I'm in town!

Chris

From Rehoboth to Myrtle, this is the best touristy beach pizza I've ever had. I expected to be disappointed, yet again, but was not. Prices are fair and the food was good enough that we ordered multiple times during our week in OBX.