Water Street Bagel Co.

Kevin Boutelle

I had an everything bagel with veggie cream cheese this morning. I wish I had taken a pic because it looked amazing. I haven't checked but I think they make their own veggie cream cheese. It tasted awesome and was made with love by Sydnie. I'll have to stop again soon.

Beyonce wood

Really liked it! The atmosphere of the place was nice. I enjoyed the music and the structure of the restaurant. It was really busy but the wait time was fair. Unfortunately, they were out of stock of the flavor I wanted for the day. So that's why I am not giving five stars. The plain bagel with butter I ordered was great with a wonderful helping of butter. I loved the fluffiness of the bagel as well. Who knew bagels could be so fresh and light that they are fluffy?! I will definitely eat from this place again. Recommend arriving early to have access to everything on the menu!

Rachel F

Overall we’ve had a lot of good experiences at water street bagel, but it’s been going downhill quickly! The last couple weekends we’ve ordered, the cream cheese is extremely lacking. The uncharge for cream cheese is quite a lot to have basically a dry bagel. I can see the bagel there’s so little cream cheese. It’s a surprise considering they use to put a ton of cream cheese on. The bagels have been stale lately and the sandwiches have been cold when we pick them up immediately after we are told they are ready. Additionally, the online ordering has been quick in the past but lately they’ve been quoting longer times and still not being ready on time.

Charlotte Sharpe

Great bagel. Chewy but with big air bubbles. A breakfast sandwich for $6 is awesome. Not a huge place but a nice street-facing counter for dine in. This is the classic on a sesame seed bagel.