Castaways On The Lake

Kelly Rounsville

Enjoyed a wonderful meal with a view overlooking Lake Ontario. Everything we had was amazing from the drinks to the dessert. Great food! Great service! Great atmosphere. My suggestion is to get there so you can watch the sunset over the lake. Priceless!

Theresa Fox

Amazing!! i went to castaways for dinner and everything was amazing the food was delicious i got honey buffalo shrimp for an appetizer and it was soooo good everything about my dinner was great from the scallops to the 2 sides i got with my dinner as well definetly worth my time and money my server christine was great told me about their worlds best homemade keylime pie and let me tell you she wasnt kidding that was better then the keylime pie i get in florida .the staff was extremely friendly and attentive i ordered a bahama mama it came in this tall glass with fruit on the rim the bartender made it just right. they even have adirondack chairs i got to sit and relax after my dinner so i could watch the sunset and i have to say it was the most beautiful sunset i've ever seen i felt like i was in the bahamas drinking my bahama mama drink i've never had a experience like that that around here before but i will be going back to try more of the delicious food options and definitely need a another slice of the best keylime pie thank you castaways for the amazing experience

Collene Doney

$178 Steak+ crab legs Steak + lobster 2 bottom shelf margaritas. We initially ordered the Shrimp Cocktail was 6 shrimp that were FROZEN the cocktail sauce my husband tried to chip at with his fork. The waitress filled up the tiny water once and my husband went with an empty glass for over 20 minutes. The waitress forgot his salad and after he reminded her he still waited an extra ten minutes for lettuce a slice of tomato and a slice of cucumber. The steak was flavorless and under cooked, the lobster was overcooked. The French fries were good and the margarita was good. If you're going to charge these prices please make sure it's worthy of the charges. I can understand being busy because it was Mother's Day but it was beyond that point.

Rachel Hall

My friend took me out to dinner for my birthday. I wanted to eat near the water. I was going to treat myself to something a little more expensive than I would usually buy for myself for lunch. I decided to get the lobster roll for $20. I ordered the lobster roll it comes with french fries and coleslaw. When my lunch came. I am always surprised that restaurants do not give you a lot of french fries it's the cheapest thing for them to sell. And the coleslaw it's in a little teeny cup. My opinion on the little lobster roll was that it was the exact same stuff that I buy at Costco's for Lobster Dip it probably cost $10. Skip on buying it there for $20. When you can make it at home and make 10 sandwiches.. I was very disappointed