Old Louisville Tavern

Laura Tetrick

My husband & I tried this place since the menu looked interesting with it's mushroom fries and it was one of the closest places to eat compared to where we were when the restaurant we had reservations at called to let us know they were closing early. I was bummed date night took a turn, but am very happy we found this place! I was going to do the ahi tuna sandwich when the server said they were out of tuna, but could substitute salmon. Again I was pretty bummed, but honestly that was one of the best salmon fillets I've ever had. It was cooked perfectly and the flavor was phenomenal. You can tell it's more of a local hangout, but with food like that I'd be a regular if it was closer. My only complaint (mild as it is) is that the fries were room temp at best and so they got soggy being on the same plate as the sandwich. Part of that is them being the thinner cut so there's only so much you can do.

All In 360

Food was great for bar food standards.Service was slower than we would like and the waitress forgot to refill our water and did not check on us regularly. Outside seating was nice but they do not allow you to rearrange tables and we had a large party so had to wait for a table to open up. Definitely recommend the truffle fries, burgers and wings! The wings were the favorite of the table. The pickle spears were a 6/10. I heard great things about the mushroom fries but they were out of them when we went (they must be good!). Good neighborhood spot to check out! Follow us for more restaurant reviews and food photography!

Karen Renata

This isn’t just neighborhood staple… it’s damn near iconic. The menu selection is nice but the taste is AH MAZING! I’ll be enjoying The Tavern salad (with an out of this world vinaigrette) and the Double Stacked Grilled Cheese Sandwich (with four cheese and cartelized onions) with fries! Please don’t sleep on this neighborhood gem!!! Go by and enjoy👉🏼 thank me later ‼️

Michael Fay

We had burgers and chicken strips and both were EXCELLENT. Delicious fries. Great atmosphere and great service. Price point was good too! My meal with a water was just $15! Definitely would go back.