Toasty's Tavern

Andrew Korfhage

It took a while to get our orders in. A couple of tables that came in after us had their food before we even had the chance to order. We finally flagged down a server and managed to get our order in. We ordered the mushroom planks, a double Cheeseburger, a regular Cheeseburger, 2 orders of fries, 2 strawberry daiquiris, and a cup of fry sauce. The mushroom planks were alright. Nothing amazing, but pretty decent. As for the burgers, I'm not really a huge smash burger style fan, but these things really hit the spot. Great flavor, and awesome toppings. Best smash burger I've ever had. The fries were great too. Super crispy, while also being soft on the inside. They taste much better than they look, and pair very well with the fry sauce. The daiquiris were really nice and strong, if a bit expensive. I do wish they had a bit more in terms of side options. It's basically just fries, or soup. Outside of the wait to order, the only other big downside was not having ice in the water. It was a bit warm in the building, so ice would have been welcomed. Ice was certainly in the daiquiris, so I'm not sure why it was absent in the water.

Jeremy Yowell

Visited Toasty's for dinner and unfortunately they were running out of menu items (hot dogs, etc). Still had a chance to try out appetizers which were definitely good, but would have liked to see draft beer options. Would likely come back again and try to snag an indoor spot.

Lauryn Capehart

Great food! I had the cooper's burger and my fiance had the cheese burger. Their jalapeño mayo is fantastic. They also have a lot of other sauces for the burger or dipping your fries. The drink I had was the "Bees knees" it was very good. Definitely recommend this place of you haven't tried it!

SVTBrian Mattingly

Very friendly staff! Fries were great. They had nice crispy texture. The burgers pretty decent and drinks are fair. Over all I enjoy this spot!