Address: 3013 Linden Ave, Dayton, OH 45410, USA
Phone: +19372531163
Sunday: Closed
Monday: 8AM–5PM
Tuesday: 8AM–5PM
Wednesday: 8AM–5PM
Thursday: 8AM–5PM
Friday: 8AM–5PM
Saturday: 8AM–5PM
Brian Shipman
Mehaffie's has some of the best pies around! A family favorite is their sugar cream pie, which tastes as close to my grandma's as I've ever found--sweet, smooth, creamy, and delicious! They just introduced a lemon chess pie, which has a nice balance of sour lemon in a sweet and creamy custard. They have quite a variety of pies, but I don't think they have a rhubarb custard like my mom bakes yet... ;)
Charles Lefeld
Not real happy. We got a cheesecake and a apple with crumb on top. The pie fell apart the second I tried to life a slice. Every single slice fell apart and there wasn’t gargle yet any apple in it. My husband had one apple slice in his slice. I never leave a remark on bad food, but you are Mchaffie pies and you are held high.
Robert Bangerter
Whenever we are in town a stop at Mehaffies is a must. Really love all their pies but our favorite is their cheesecake on a stick. It is the perfect match to a hot summer day.
dragonchick 19
Lol I feel I should just have a drop off at my house my kiddo loves there turtle cheesecake so much we have to get a cheesecake a week ...
Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.
Yes I agree, very conscientious. Wearing mask, very clean. All the pies store in cases. And limited of people. I was the only one. Great pies, great price.
Depends on how many you buy they have delivery vans and deliver to grocery stores all over dayton and surrounding suburbs
I don't believe so
Yes u can depending thr kind it is i believe has sum to do wit how good but yes most definitely can
Just buy a whole pie. It's a lot cheaper than by the slice.
I dont know what those are but there lies are great! a Dayton classic
All their pies are pre-cooked, just like nearly every pie sold in every store in America. If you want to heat it up, heat it up, but you don't need to cook it.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.
Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.