Carfagna's

Category: Italian grocery store

Address: 1440 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH 43240, USA

Phone: +16148466340

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–5PM

Monday: 10AM–7PM

Tuesday: 10AM–7PM

Wednesday: 10AM–7PM

Thursday: 10AM–7PM

Friday: 10AM–7PM

Saturday: 10AM–7PM

Reviews

Emma Zglinicki

May 23, 2022

While I do LOVE the market, the restaurant leaves a lot to be desired. We ordered our food and it came out extraordinarily fast. And while that's nice, the quality wasn't much better than that you'd find at Olive Garden. The pasta wasn't tossed and finished in the sauce, which is an absolute must with Italian food. Our server was nice, it was a little awkward waiting for him to input the order on his handheld device as it took a while. We were also charged for bread (that we didn't ask for but was brought out like normal bread service) which I thought was odd. Overall, it's average Italian. Nothing to really write home about. I'd rather go to a small family owned place with better flavors.

Josh Talbert

Jan 19, 2022

New location is very cool. Liquor selection is fantastic. Meat counter has some unique things prices aren't great but it's about the same pricing as other fancy grocery stores. Definitely will be back for special items and store made pasta.

B C

Dec 18, 2021

The event i was at this week was catered by this restaurant. It was rather pitiful to say the least, especially considering the price. one of the days the food was so disturbing i refused to eat it & can’t believe they even served the food looking like this. i have attached a photo (it’s supposed to be chicken breast). do yourself a favor, order elsewhere. this is REPULSIVE.

Shelby Booker

Oct 20, 2021

Out with the old and in with the new. Carfagna's is back in a big way. The new building is large, clean and packed with a whole bunch of goodies, including a fully stocked liquor store and restaurant. They really went all out. Great products and amazing employees. 5/5

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

How good is the meatball mix

pearl armentrout | Jun 28, 2018
Charlesie Love | Jun 29, 2018

They r one of 3 places that have old fashion hotdogs (beef & pork) and the casing and string. U can buy one or 21... Love their meatballs and great sales.

Read More

Do they accept credit cards?

Lynn Chau | Jun 27, 2020
shawn milner | Jun 28, 2020

Yes whatever card u have

Read More

I'm wondering about the spiral hams at Carfagna's. How are they?

Rebecca Rader | Jun 27, 2020
Karen Robinson | Jun 28, 2020

Great..

Read More

Do you have a standing rib roast?

Patrick Riley | Jun 27, 2020
Patrick Riley | Jun 28, 2020

How much per pound and what is the average size please.

Is the meat grass fed/antibiotic/hormone free?

Chrisitne Horvath | Jun 28, 2019
Michael Stalling | Jun 29, 2019

No but it's actually very very good

Read More

Does Carfagnas sell lamb chops?

Shawn Jones | Jun 28, 2019
Ryan McBurney | Jun 29, 2019

Yes

Read More

Do you sell unfilled cannoli shells

Diana Ruggerio | Jun 28, 2019
Lewis King | Jun 29, 2019

Yes, they do.

Read More

I still remember their delicious ham salad my mom used to buy there 35 years ago. It's the best ever! Do they still sell it?

Heidi Strawn | Jun 28, 2019
Lisa Panzica | Jun 29, 2019

Yes

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Apr 28, 2021
Kelly Mitchell | Apr 29, 2021

Face masks are required. Social distance is requested. Wipe down check outs and counters after each customer.

Do they sell double 0 flour?

Mary Folchetti | Oct 30, 2020
Joseph Marcum | Oct 31, 2020

Yes they do

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places