Portobello's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

C M

Move over Olive Garden - the REAL Italians have come to town!!! I found this place by accident while making a turn around for my GPS to another restaurant, but the "hole in the wall" esthetic lured me in. What they lack in curb appeal, they make up for by being some of the best Italian food I've ever had. The bread sticks come out piping hot and misshapenly perfect - a welcome change from their uniformly bland commercial counterparts! The Primavera is decadent and creamy and the vegetables perfectly done. The italian authenticity doesn't stop at the food - at one point the cook could be heard yelling at someone in Italian in the kitchen, enhancing the experience even further. This place has earned a very special place in my heart, as well as my stomach. 10/10 Caio Bella ❤

Lindsey Rogers

I was charged $54.36 for two medium Hawaiian pizzas this weekend. Yes, $54! Absolutely ludicrous. The pizzas were thin and extremely greasy to the point where we didn’t want to eat them. We are done with Portobello’s and that’s a shame. Since we moved to this area several years ago, we have been loyal customers. We have tried everything and loved their pizza, their Italian meals, their strombolis, their cheesesteaks. We supported them during the pandemic and were willing to spend more for their food because we felt it was worth it and important to back a local business. But the quality the past several visits has not been the same and the price just keeps climbing. Now there’s an extra charge for paying with a card?! There’s more affordable options out there.

Joel Davenport

A great locally owned eatery. Best pizza on Highway 58, but also made-to-order pasta dishes! Maria is amazing!

Don Vacks

Okay I don't know where to start, but this is ridicoulous... The food looks like its been frozen then defrosted, 3 plain meatballs... The salad came with 1 single cherry tomato and it seem like 4 piece of grated cheese... The bread it came with wasn't fresh at all... And all of this for $40 and to top everything else the lady taking the order at the counter wasnt friendly at all... Never again, paid way too much, overpriced!