Thiel's American Pie

shawn D

Great pizza and even better service.

n0stal6ic

Very good pizzas and ice cream. The delivery service is great too.

Kathleen Kappenman

Definitely one of my favorite pizza spots. I’m located in Minneapolis and will gladly travel (and have multiple times) just to get a pie and bring it home. The crust is the best and it’s always cooked to perfection. Would have gotten the full pizza in the photo but eating obviously took priority.

Brian McGee

I love this place! It is the absolute textbook picture of a small town American restaurant. It’s small, it’s tucked away, it’s dated, there’s random stuff everywhere but it’s just… awesome. It’s a pizza place, with an ice cream cooler, with a little nook where they sell touristy stuff, a case where they sell other odd items, American flags and other decorations everywhere… it’s just a place that screams pride. A rare place in a time like this. Oh and I forgot to mention, the pizza is also great too. They’ve got gluten free in two different sizes, including a 14 inch, very uncommon. The sauce is sweet, the cheese is fresh and the crust has just the right amount of burn and crisp to it. They also cook and present the gluten free pizza on a separate cardboard plate. The staff was all incredible too. Everyone is extremely polite and friendly. We bought a couple of the touristy items and the staff member accidentally dropped other items, scattering them inside the case. Instead of getting frustrated, she just says “oh well, I’ll get to it tomorrow when I open”, only to a couple minutes later fix what fell without a sign of frustration. They were getting slammed with orders and didn’t let anything phase them at all. If you see this place and you’re passing through, give them your business! If you’re making a plan to be in town, add this spot to your itinerary!