Jimmy's Pizza

Nick Reynolds

I'm going to preface this - they were having a carnival and Jimmy's was slammed. Every other time I have been here it's 5 stars! They missed this time. Food was 40 minutes PAST the time they said it would be ready, wings were undercooked and pizza was cold. Like I said, every other time 5 stars so will definitely come again.

Stephen Balza

One of the only places open for dinner on a Sunday evening in Silver Bay. It looks like it will as a DQ at one point and my wife was delighted to find that they sold soft serve ice cream (including her favorite…twist cones). Like most every other place in North America, they are hurting for staff. The employees were friendly and hustling but were a bit overwhelmed. The pizza was average but hot, fresh, and reasonably priced.

Amy Fuhry

Get some delicious Italian food to warm up your insides after being at chilly Lake Superior! Highly recommend the pizza, chicken alfredo, lasagna & spaghetti! Yummy milkshakes too!

Kaylee Aleshire

We were visiting from out of town and really wanted to try this place. Ordered the cheese bread, which was great! We got a deep dish ( please keep in mind, deep dish here is more hand tossed but very good), meats pizza. Friendly staff, clean restaurant. Would recommend!