Tony's Pizzeria

Shayna Harriman

Excellent customer service. They also do a little magic with their crust. Best I've had in a looong time.

Sam Gibson

Best pizza in Dansville. My only wish is they had fresh mushrooms and and offered artichoke hearts 😁

Holly Jacobs

I won't get pizza anywhere else, it is by far the best in Dansville and the tri-county area. Subs are awesome too, my favorite is the Chicken Finger sub! I wish they had their broccoli cheddar soup all the time!

Captain Creed

Used to come here regularly before the pandemic, but since then would order out. This time called ahead and ordered a 2 cheese pizzas like usual because my family doesn't eat pork so obviously no pepperoni. The woman that took my order asked for my name and number. Would that be all is the only thing she asked besides that. I walk in and already the customer service isn't the greatest coming from the older woman. I take my order and leave, but only then realized they gave me pepperoni instead of a plain cheese. Walking back in with my sister I say excuse me I ordered 2 plain cheese pizzas but got pepperoni instead. Instantly the older woman starts to argue saying no you ordered pepperoni and that she wrote it down that way and read it back to me on the phone. She did no such thing. I explained I don't eat pork so I wouldn't order pepperoni. She keeps insisting. The younger woman tells her to make us new pizzas and ushers me aside to take a new customer when we weren't even done discussing everything. You could visibly see the older woman in the back glaring back and slamming things. I no longer wanted anything to do with that place so the replacement order was canceled before it was started and we walked out. I forgot to get a refund being so frustrated with that experience so I called back for a refund. The younger woman on the phone said they don't give refunds because she offered to make a replacement and that I could get the pizzas back that I returned. That makes no sense because one, they didn't get a chance to even start the new pizza because it was canceled. Two, as stated if I don't eat pork why would I go get the pizza's they messed up? I said "I don't want any pizza from you, just a simple refund". But she insisted just because of the offer there wouldn't be one. I no longer plan on supporting this business. The customer service was never the greatest before, but the food is no longer worth it.