They will make u wait. Especially if your other card is still on.
They print them out on the spot now only if you tell them something like it's not swiping cause something is wrong with the strip. But if you tell them it was stolen they will cancel it so nobody else can use it and you will have to wait for a new one in the mail.Also if you tell them it was lost they will cancel it also, so better to just say it's not working and if they ask for it say you left it at home and they will print you a new one and just tell you to cut up the other one.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.