Can I still go the next day and get in the attractions that weren't punched on the earlier day? With the same ticket?

Yes, you can.

I don't believe thru would allow that but they also don't shut down until everyone has had their ticket punched for every ride. We got there around 8:30 pm and even though it says they close at 11:00 pm, we were there until midnight and there were still others in line. They may shut the gate at 11:00, but they keep working until has gone through.

I honestly don't think anyone would know since they do not date the ticket cards that get punched

No you can not. They are same-day tickets.

no, I would call and complain and see if you can get tickets for a different day

Oh OK thanks