I have bought from a resale website before and called venue to confirm their authenticity. Wishing you all the best!
While they may be "real" that doesn't mean that someone didn't sell those same tickets multiple times. Basically whoever gets there first gets to see the show. The venue cannot allow the tickets in if another pair has already been scanned in.
Call the venue
Call the Peabody!
Call them .....
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.