Get there for 3.30 if you want to get a sitting for 6.30 or 7.30. They open the door at 5.45 and the start taking reservations then. The calzone is the best I've had. They don't take reservations.
Waw ! Yeah not worth it
I went there with my family. Had to wait from 4.30pm just to arrange a booking at 5.30, for 8pm! There was loads to do in the meantime around Brooklyn, so we were okay. But if it wasn't on my son and daughter's wish list, I'd never, ever, go there.
No, they don't do reservations a day ahead, or any days ahead. If you want to sit down, you have to wait in line 2-3hrs before they open to get a table for that day. It's probably not worth it.
Try ordering a pizza togo after 9...to get a table you have to get there VERY early
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.