You can go to the Bellefontaine Cemetery & Arboretum (BCA) website and find grave search on the home page. There is a William Hibler who was buried on June 15, 1890 in Lot/grave 217 in Public Lot Section F. I did not find any Hiblers. You can visit BCA where you can obtain a map of BCA and directions on finding a grave. I am a volunteer Greeter at BCA.
Please call the main office number and ask. They have records of all 87,000 + burials.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.