You might also be able to check at the rectory of Asdumption Church. They have some cemetery records there. They are on First Street in Peekskill. Is the name on the stone Muller?
I don't know that either, but, when you pull into the place, come up the hill. Stop at the first building on your right. That's the office. They can help you.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.