I would take the train for a safe peaceful ride or you could take Megabus it's cheap and you get what you pay for
Have you ever thought of train much better ride
There are charter buses that leave DC area to New York every 4 hours. it is approximately a 4 hour trip and they run around $40 round trip. Google Charter buses to New York from DC it should pull up a list of them in area
Amtrak station at BWI....great way to get to New York.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.