Mojo bbq (get the whole hog-sample of all the meats they offer and several sides-fed 5 of us with it), Meghans Irish pub, Harry's are all excellent dining choices and downtown.
We enjoyed the prohibition kitchen very cool great Burger Downtown where all the shops are
Caddy shack is best
Murray Brothers Caddyshack and Villagio Grille in the Renaissance Hotel which also has a bar called The Bar at Villagio. All the other best options are in downtown st. Augustine.
St. Mary's Seafood is good. Left out of the Village about 1 mile
Caddyshack, nice atmosphere, good food.
Caddyshack is really good- I enjoyed the spinach and artichoke dip and steak sandwich last time I was there! If you drive south on I95 to the exit for Highway 16, you'll find a lot of fast food restaurants, too.
Murray Bros. Caddyshack
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.