Your registration paper isn't necessary. They won't even ask you for it. They will only ask for your i.d. and the vehicle for which you are renewing registration.
Just go there with your drivers license, all your vehicles are under it.
I would say you would have to get another registration paper. Just $5-10 Buck's then get another sticker to go with it for $5-10 Buck's..
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.